Top5Ranked.com is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

DeWalt vs Ryobi Cordless Impact Driver [How To Choose]

The top rivals in the power tools segment include DeWalt and Ryobi. These two companies are known for making some of the best impact drivers that can handle all your needs. They have multiple models so that you can choose the one that works best for various applications.

Since both companies are good at what they do, sometimes it is hard to pick a favorite. It is why we came up with this guide to review the DeWalt DCF887M2 and the Ryobi P238 impact drivers. They both offer good value for money with subtle differences between them. Let us dive into the reviews already.

Quick Summary

Both DeWalt DCF887M2 and Ryobi P238 models are easy to use considering they come with simple controls. Users also find them ideal for multiple applications because of the variable speed settings. You simply adjust the speed of the impact drill depending on the use. They also have brushless motors, which promise better performance, durability, and long working hours.

As for differences, the DeWalt model is pricier as compared to the Ryobi model. If you are on a budget, then the Ryobi model can deliver the performance you have always wanted at a bargain.

DeWalt DCF887M2 and Ryobi P238 18V Impact Driver

DeWalt DCF887M2 MAX XR Impact Driver Kit

DEWALT 20V MAX XR Impact Driver Kit, Brushless, 3-Speed, 1/4-Inch, 4.0-Ah (DCF887M2)

DeWalt integrates its best technology into this impact driver to make it stand out from the competitors. Such features include brushless motor, variable speed settings, improved batteries and much more. We look at these features in detail below.

Brushless Motor

The brushless motor in the DCF887M2 model is meant to improve its lifespan. Brushless motors do not need regular maintenance and can run for a long time. These motors also deliver an increased power output and more speed. It should now be easy to use the drill for hours without worrying about degradation in performance.

Multiple Speed Settings

You might have different applications for an impact driver. The three-speed settings of the unit make it ideal for you to switch to whichever speed you need for the job. The available speeds to the user include 1,000 RPM, 2,800 RPM, and 3,250 RPM.

Still, the impact driver has the precision drive feature at the low speeds. Such a feature is good for those who need more accuracy and efficiency. For jobs that do not need delicate handling, then go for a higher speed.

LED Lights

The LED lights added onto the impact driver improves the convenience of using it. The lights help with better visibility when working in poorly lit areas. These lights have a delay of 20 seconds once you release the trigger. For most people, having a built-in light is a must. It makes the tool versatile.

The Batteries

Considering it is a cordless impact drill, then the type of batteries you get with the unit are important. This one comes with impressive lithium ion batteries. These 4.0ah batteries offer a higher capacity so that you end up with a longer run time per charge.

Power and Control

As much as this DeWalt impact driver is compact, it does not mean that the power is compromised. This is because the model delivers an impressive 3,600 impacts per minute. The amount of torque also varies depending on what you need to achieve. The torque options include 240, 1500, and 1825 in. lbs.

The drill is lightweight. Such weight is important for control of the drill. Even if you use it for several hours, it does not feel too heavy on your hands.

What We Liked

  • The unit has a precision drive feature
  • The brushless motor is powerful
  • This drill has adjustable speed settings
  • The unit has an easy to grip handle
  • Comes with two batteries as part of the kit

What We Didn’t Like

  • The location of the reverse button is not ideal

The Solution: As much as the location of the reverse button might not be ideal, you get used to it with time. As you keep using the impact driver, it gets easier to engage reverse.

Ryobi P238 18V Impact Driver

Ryobi P238 18V One+ Brushless 1/4 2,000 Inch Pound, 3,100 RPM Cordless Impact Driver w/ Gripzone Overmold, Belt Clip, and Tri-Beam LED (Power Tool Only, Battery Not Included)

The Ryobi P238 is a worthy competitor to the DeWalt DCF887M2 model mentioned above. The best part about the Ryobi is that it offers similar features, but an affordable than DeWalt. Let us see what this unit has for us in store.

Variable Speed Settings

The P238 unit comes with up to 3 speed settings. You now have an easy time adjusting the speed of the drill depending on the job. For simple jobs, then the lower speeds should be ideal. The top-mounted speed switch makes it easy to switch from one speed to another. The maximum speed you can get from the unit is 3,100 RPM.

Grip

The usability of any impact driver is important. It is why this one comes with an over-molded gripzone. The rubber molding increases the friction between your hand and tool. With such ergonomics, you will have maximum control over the drill even in the slippery environments.

Tri-Beam LED

Since lights seem to be a must-have feature for most impact drivers, this one comes with a Tri-Beam LED setup. The LED lights help you see better when working in tight spaces.

Brushless Motor

You can never go wrong with an impact drill having a brushless motor. This type of motor works quieter and cooler for longer hours. Even if you had to work for several hours, you might just be limited by the battery life. The motor gives you an impressive torque of 2,000-inch pound. Driving through various materials should now be easier.

Belt Clip

To further improve on its usability, the unit comes with a belt clip. This clip allows you to easily hang the drill on your belt if you are working. Keeping it in an easy to reach position should make working easier and faster.

What We Liked

  • You get variable speed settings
  • The grip is good for ease of control
  • The LED lights aid in working in dark areas
  • It delivers impressive torque

What We Didn’t Like

  • The battery runtime could be better

The Solution: The battery life is mostly affected by the amount of time the LED lights are ON. If you want to save more on battery life, only use the LED lights when necessary.

Which is Better?

The type of project will mostly decide what type of impact drill you get to choose. For our case, both the DeWalt and Ryobi models are good for multiple projects. However, the DeWalt model stands out as the best to use for the toughest jobs. You will also feel that the DeWalt DCF887M2 model has a better build quality. This improves the overall durability and functionality of the unit.

P238 Ryobi is not bad either. It does come with multiple important features you would enjoy. At this point, it is easy to see that the DeWalt DCF887M2 model is better. It will always live up to your expectations, even if it means spending a little bit more to get it.

Final Thoughts

You might get misinformed periodically about these two models. However, from the information above about their features, you are now in a better position to make up your mind. You should consider the type of project you want to handle and any crucial features you think are necessary. Ryobi stands out as a DIY impact drill for home projects, while the DeWalt unit is best for professional and tough tasks.